Restricted Choice: The Finesse That Feels Wrong But Works

You’re missing the queen and jack of a suit. You lead small toward dummy’s ace-king. Left-hand opponent plays the jack. Do you finesse on the next round (playing for the queen to be on your left too), or do you play for the drop (hoping the queen falls under your remaining honor)?

Your gut says: “They played the jack, so they probably have the queen too. Play for the drop.”

Your gut is wrong.

The Principle of Restricted Choice says you should finesse. Not because it feels right, but because the mathematics of how cards are dealt makes it roughly 2-to-1 in your favor. When one honor appears, the missing honor is twice as likely to be in the other hand than doubleton in the same hand.

This principle is one of the most counter-intuitive concepts in bridge, and one of the most powerful. Get comfortable with it, and you’ll win an extra trick or two every session. Ignore it, and you’ll be taking losing lines while wondering why the percentages never seem to work.

What Is the Principle of Restricted Choice?

The Principle of Restricted Choice applies when an opponent plays one of two equivalent cards, and you need to know whether they started with both cards or just one.

The principle says: When an opponent plays one of two or more equivalent cards, assume they didn’t have a choice. They played the only card they had.

In practice, this means when the jack appears and you’re missing both the jack and queen, you should play as if the queen is in the other hand. Not always—bridge has no “always”—but as the percentage play when you have no other information.

The Classic Example

You hold:

Dummy: ♥AK1032
Declarer: ♥9654

You’re missing the queen and jack. You cash the ace, and West plays the jack. On the next round, do you finesse the 10 (playing West for the singleton jack), or do you play the king (playing West for QJ doubleton)?

Restricted Choice says: Finesse.

When West plays the jack, one of two things happened:

  1. West had J alone and had no choice but to play it.
  2. West had QJ doubleton and chose to play the jack instead of the queen.

Both holdings are equally likely before West plays a card. But once West plays the jack, situation #1 becomes twice as likely as situation #2, because in situation #2, West could have played the queen instead.

The math says finesse for the 10. You’ll win roughly 2 times out of 3.

The Mathematical Reasoning

Before you play the suit, there are three relevant ways the missing cards can lie:

  1. West has J alone, East has Qxx (finesse wins)
  2. West has Q alone, East has Jxx (finesse wins)
  3. West has QJ doubleton, East has xx (drop wins)

At first glance: “Three equally likely situations, so it’s 50-50.”

But that’s not how probability works once West plays a card.

The Bayesian Logic

When West plays the jack from QJ, West made a choice. West could have played the queen instead. Roughly half the time West would play the queen; half the time, the jack.

Think of it this way:

  • Scenario A: West has J alone → plays J 100% of the time
  • Scenario B: West has QJ → plays J only 50% of the time

You observed the jack. Scenario A (100% produces a jack) is twice as likely as Scenario C (50% produces a jack).

The Exact Odds

With nine cards between your hand and dummy, when West plays the jack:

  • West had J alone: Finesse wins. Probability: 50%
  • West had QJ: Drop wins. Probability: 40%, but we only see the jack half the time = 20%

Adjusted odds: 50% vs 20% = Finesse is 2.5-to-1 favorite.

Don’t worry if the exact math makes your head hurt. The key insight is: finesse is roughly twice as good as playing for the drop.

When to Apply Restricted Choice

Restricted choice applies in specific situations. You need:

  1. Two or more missing equivalent honors (usually Q and J, sometimes other combinations)
  2. One of those honors appears from a defender
  3. A finesse is available on the next round

The principle tells you to play as if the defender who played the honor didn’t have the other equivalent honor.

The Situations Where It Applies

Situation 1: Missing QJ, One Drops

Dummy: ♠AK1093
You: ♠7652

Cash the ace, LHO plays the jack. On the next round, finesse the 10.

This is the textbook case. You’ll see it a few times every session.

Situation 2: Missing J10, One Drops

Dummy: ♦AKQ93
You: ♦7652

Cash the ace, LHO plays the 10. On the next round, finesse the 9.

Same principle. The 10 and jack are equivalent. When one appears, play for the other to be in the opposite hand.

Situation 3: Missing Three Honors, One Drops

Dummy: ♥AK1098
You: ♥7652

You’re missing QJ5. Cash the ace, LHO plays the jack. Finesse the 10 on the next round.

The jack could be from QJ, J5, or singleton. Singleton is most likely once the jack appears.

Situation 4: Two-Way Finesse Situations

Dummy: ♠AK109
You: ♠7652

You can finesse either direction. If you cash the king first and East plays the jack, finesse through West on the next round (leading toward the 109 and playing the 10).

Restricted choice tells you which way to finesse after you see an honor.

Worked Examples in Full Context

Example 1: Making Your Slam

Contract: 6♠
Trump: AK1093 in dummy, 7652 in hand

You have 11 top tricks. You cash the ace of trumps, and LHO plays the ♠J.

With restricted choice: Finesse the 10 on the next round. LHO’s jack is more likely to be singleton than from QJ. You make your slam 2 out of 3 times instead of 1 out of 3.

Example 2: The Two-Way Guess

Dummy: ♥AK109
You: ♥7652

You cash the king, and East drops the jack. Lead low toward dummy on the next round and finesse the 10. East’s jack is more likely to be singleton than from QJ. Restricted choice breaks the two-way tie.

Example 3: Combining With Other Information

Dummy: ♦AK1093
You: ♦7652

You cash the ace, West plays the jack. But West opened the bidding and has already shown up with 10 HCP in other suits. If West had QJ of this suit, that would be 13+ HCP.

The play: Restricted choice says finesse, but the bidding says West can’t have both honors. Finesse with extra confidence—it’s 95%+, not just 67%.

Common Situations in Suit Combinations

The Eight-Card Fit (Missing QJx)

Dummy: ♠AK1032, You: ♠9654

The classic. Cash the ace. If an honor appears, finesse on the next round through the hand that played the honor. You’ll see this several times every session.

The Nine-Card Fit (Missing QJ)

Dummy: ♥AK10932, You: ♥8654

With nine cards, some players automatically play for the drop. Don’t. If an honor appears on the first round, restricted choice still applies. Finesse on the next round.

Missing J10 Instead of QJ

Dummy: ♦AKQ93, You: ♦7652

The principle works for any equivalent honors. If someone plays the 10, finesse the 9 on the next round. The jack and 10 are equivalent from the defender’s perspective.

When Restricted Choice Does NOT Apply

Restricted choice is powerful, but it’s not universal. Know when to ignore it.

Reason 1: The Cards Aren’t Equivalent

If you have the 10 in your hand instead of dummy, the jack and queen aren’t equivalent from the defender’s perspective. Playing the jack might be tactical, not forced. Don’t apply restricted choice when the cards aren’t equivalent.

Reason 2: You Have a Better Line

With nine or more cards, playing for the drop is often still better than finessing. Don’t blindly follow restricted choice when the normal percentage play is to cash your honors.

Reason 3: The Bidding Tells You Otherwise

If West opened 1NT and you can see 20 HCP between your hand and dummy, West can’t have both missing honors without having too many points. The bidding overrides restricted choice.

Reason 4: Defensive Signals Give It Away

If RHO’s signal shows three cards in the suit, LHO has two. Restricted choice says finesse, but the defensive signal says drop. Trust partnership signals over restricted choice when they conflict.

Reason 5: You Can’t Afford the Finesse

If you’re in 3NT with eight top tricks and losing the lead is fatal, don’t risk the contract on a 2-to-1 shot. Find a sure 9th trick elsewhere. Don’t apply restricted choice when losing the finesse is fatal.

Restricted Choice in Defensive Play

Restricted choice applies to defenders too. If you’re East and partner plays the jack, restricted choice says partner is more likely to have a singleton than QJ doubleton. Use this to guide your defense when you can see dummy and your hand.

Common Mistakes

Mistake 1: Applying It When You Shouldn’t

The biggest mistake is using restricted choice blindly. If you have nine or ten cards, playing for the drop is often still correct. If the bidding places both honors in one hand, ignore restricted choice.

Always combine restricted choice with other information.

Mistake 2: Forgetting It Applies

You see the jack, you play for the drop without thinking, and you go down. You forgot about restricted choice.

Make it a habit: When an honor appears from a defender and you’re missing two equivalent honors, ask yourself: “Should I finesse on the next round?”

Mistake 3: Thinking It’s 100%

Restricted choice makes the finesse about 2-to-1 favorite. That means it loses 1 time in 3. When it loses, don’t beat yourself up. You took the percentage play.

Think in the long term. Over 100 hands, you’ll gain significantly by using restricted choice.

Mistake 4: Confusing It With Other Principles

Restricted choice is not the same as “eight ever, nine never” (which says finesse with eight cards, play for the drop with nine). That saying is about initial odds. Restricted choice is about updating your odds after an honor appears.

Restricted choice updates your thinking mid-play, not at the beginning.

Mistake 5: Ignoring Tempo

Sometimes you can’t afford to finesse because you need to pull trumps immediately, or you can’t afford to give up the lead. Restricted choice tells you the best percentage play, but bridge is more than percentages.

Factor in the whole hand, not just one suit in isolation.

The Psychology of Restricted Choice

Good defenders will sometimes false-card, playing the jack from Qx, trying to talk you out of the finesse. But if they false-card from a doubleton, they just turned a 2-to-1 favorite into 100% for you.

Most of the time, defenders play randomly from equivalent honors. Trust the mathematics over paranoia. Don’t overthink it. Take the percentage play.

Advanced Applications

The Repeated Finesse

If you cash the ace and LHO plays the jack, then finesse the 10 and it wins, finesse again. Restricted choice says LHO didn’t have the queen, so keep finessing until you see the queen or someone shows out.

Combining With Other Information

When the finesse works, you know where the missing honor is. That places cards in a specific hand, which might help with squeeze or endplay decisions. Restricted choice gives you information, not just a trick.

The Deep Principle

Restricted choice is counter-intuitive because it asks you to ignore your instinct. Your instinct says: “They played the jack, so they probably have the queen too.”

But probability doesn’t care about instinct. When a defender plays one of two equivalent cards, they’re twice as likely to have played their only card than to have chosen between two.

The beauty of restricted choice is that it’s pure logic. No partnership agreement required. No memory of conventions. Just Bayesian probability applied to a common card-play situation.

Learn it, trust it, and use it. Over time, you’ll pick up tricks that other players miss, and you’ll make finesses that feel wrong but work more often than not.

That’s the power of mathematics in bridge. It doesn’t lie, it doesn’t guess, and it doesn’t care how things feel. It just wins.

Back to Encyclopedia